Update 2/6/2016 – CAMP MAGEE TEMPORARILY HALTED
Camp Magee has been temporarily dismantled – the magnitude of public and media attention generated by the “Bear” has been such, that the State Government is “more actively” progressing their review of the MRC’s occupation of the Caulfield Racecourse and Recreation Reserve.
Therefore, Camp Magee and next Saturday’s wrap up session are now deferred to give the newly appointed Minister (Lily Ambrosio) time to assess the current situation and determine the best way forward.
The “Bear”, with his tent, promises to return if required (something we hope doesn’t eventuate).
A big thank you to the “Bear”, the media and the public for their efforts in highlighting this significant issue.
For those of you who missed viewing the centre parkland while Jim was in residence, don’t let that deter you from visiting the centre parkland. It’s an awesome sight and a tremendous community asset that is under utilized by the community.
Update 31/5/2016 – The Age 31/5/2016 – The Age
GERA original posting – 28/5/2016 below
Cr. Jim “Bear Grylls” Magee has set up a week long camp* on the 5584 sqm of neglected crown land located near the Glen Eira Road roundabout. This land was a major part of the infamous land swap and was to become parkland that provided visual and physical above ground pedestrian access to the public parkland in the centre of the racecourse.
The purpose of “Bear” Magee’s camp out is to highlight the inequitable racing vs public use of the Crown Land known as the Caulfield Racecourse and Recreation Reserve and the need for Government action. The camp out will end next Saturday (4/6/2016) at 1.00 p.m. with a wrap up session attended by the Minister responsible for the Reserve’s management (the newly appointed Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change – Lily D’Ambrosio), the Minister for Sport (John Eren) and various media representatives. Residents are also urged to attend to show their support for the “opening up” of the Racecourse for public parkland usage.
* You can follow “Bear” Magee’s progress on Twitter
For those of you who don’t know, we re-iterate – the Caulfield Racecourse and Recreation Reserve was created by a Crown Grant in 1858 with the grant being formally enacted in 1876. Under that Grant and all subsequent legislation, the primely located Reserve has 3 separate yet equal purposes of racecourse, public park and public recreation ground (ie. 33% racing and 67% public usage).
As per the scathing Auditor General’s Report (September, 2014), since the late 1990s mismanagement by the Board of Trustees and lack of Governmental oversight, has resulted in the Reserve’s current 54 hectares (valued at $2 bn) having the following usages*
- 11 hectares (20%), is leased by the Melbourne Racing Club (MRC) for a flat rate of approx. $170,000 p.a. The lease revenue is paid to the Trustees who generally return it to the MRC to fund racing related projects (as opposed to parkland related projects). All revenue derived from the commercial activities (including the Glasshouse Tabaret) held on the Reserve land is retained by the MRC.
- 37 hectares (69%) is used by MRC without any clear legal entitlement or payment arrangement.
- 6 hectares (11%) is open space for potential use by the community 328 days p.a. (ie. excluding racing – 27 days p.a. and major MRC commercial event days – 10 days p.a.) and during prescribed hours (ie. 10 am. to dusk). The 6 ha is not visible from the surrounding streets, is difficult to physically access and comprises limited facilities that don’t meet park users’ needs.
* ie. 89% racing and 11% public usage
In short, the Auditor General’s Report (which concurred with the findings of the earlier 2008 Legislative Council Select Committee Report on Crown Land Management) found that “the current Crown land management arrangements over the reserve are untenable from a public interest perspective …. attention urgently required”.
21 months after the tabling of the AG’s report there’s been talk but little action on the part of the Government. Meanwhile
- the above usages and leasing arrangements remain in place, to the advantage of the MRC and the detriment of the public.
- the centre of the racecourse, which is the area originally set aside for public usage, sits empty most days (except for the 27 race days and 10 major event days p.a. when it is used as a car park) and every evening after dusk
- innumerable children and adults are unable to play sport or train within their own Municipality because demand far exceeds supply.
“Bear” Magee is asking, on behalf of residents, for the Reserve’s current inequitable usages to be aligned with the three separate yet equal purposes. Undertaking a week long camp out (without any facilities) in Melbourne, in June, is no mean feat. GERA thanks him for his efforts and is a strong supporter of the cause. GERA also urges residents to show their support by
- going to view what they are missing out on (by accessing the racecourse centre via the Glen Eira Road Tunnel), then stopping for a chat with “Bear” Magee afterwards, and
- attending the camp out wrap up session next Saturday.
Finally, words of wisdom from the past
The Argus, 16th August, 1884 (8 years after Grown Grant was enacted).
Extract of a meeting between the Minister of Lands (Mr. Tucker) and VATC (Victorian Amateur Turf Club, later became the MRC) re management of the reserve being vested in the VATC
“It seemed to him (Mr. Tucker) that to agree to the proposals of the club would be to limit to some extent the right of the public to use the ground for the purposes for which it was originally reserved – namely, for recreation and a public park. … The vicinity of the Caulfield racecourse would no doubt soon be thickly populated, and the value of the reserve to the public would then be widely enhanced. … Mr. Tucker said he thought the public ought not to have to ask for permission to go on a public reserve. ”
28/5/2016 – Residents wanting to play sport at the Glen Eira Road Tunnel Entrance Gates